Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

18 Bay Restaurant

$$$

Italian

Bella Vita Pizza

$$

Pizza

Bobs Fish Market Restaurant

$$

Seafood

Cafe 27

$$

Restaurants

Chucks Bar & Grill

$$

Sports Bars, Burgers, Beer, Wine & Spirits

Clarks Fish House

$$

Seafood

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

$$

Seafood Markets

Elli's Country Store

$$

Sandwiches

Kyle's

$$

Caterers

Maria's Kitchen

$$

Food

Marias Kitchen

$$

Mexican

Marie Eiffel Market

$$

Food

SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill

$$

Seafood

Shelter Island Seafood

$$

Seafood Markets

Shelter Island Slice

$$

Pizza

Shelter Island Whale's Tale

$

Cafes

Sunset Beach Hotel

$$

Food

The Boathouse Shelter Island

$$

Restaurants

The Dory

$$

American

The Eccentric Bagel

$$

Delis

The Islander

$$

Food

The Islander

$$

Bars, New American

The Lettuce Lady

$$

Salad

The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

$$

New American

Tuck Shop

$$

Ice Cream

Vine Street Café

$$$

Bars, New American

Wades Beach

$$

Food